Credits disappear when every soft fail gets “one more try.” A keep/kill rubric turns taste into a short score so you stop paying for the same mistake.
Score each take in 30 seconds
Give 0–2 points on four axes (max 8):
- Identity — same adult as the source still?
- Motion clarity — can you name the single action without squinting?
- Artefacts — hands, teeth, edges, flicker?
- Usable length — is there a 1–2s keepable beat?
Keep at 6+. Retry with one change at 4–5. Kill the brief at 3 or below.
What “one change” means
Either tighten the crop, simplify the motion verb, switch template family, or shorten duration. Not all four. If the second try also lands ≤5, the brief is wrong—not the model.
When more credits will not help
- Source still is blurry, mirrored, or full of unrelated people.
- You asked for two conflicting actions in one clip.
- You are chasing a celebrity likeness or a real person you do not have rights to—stop.
Log the kills
Keep a one-line note: v3 kill — hands + identity drift — try standing template next. Future you will spend fewer credits than future you who “remembers” vibes.
Adults 18+ only. Pair this rubric with your consent/rights checklist before any upload.